Menus

Irish Soda Bread

Studded with raisins and caraway, this is outstanding with butter & honey and makes a great sandwich too!

$7

$4

Buttercream Cupcakes

Baileys Irish Cream, Thin Mint with Chocolate Cake, or Guinness Stout with Vanilla/Chocolate Cinnamon Swirl. Also, yellow or chocolate cake with shamrock design!

$2.75

Thin Mint Hoho's

Our chocolate Cake rolled with Thin Mint Whipped Cream. Nuff said:)

$2.95

Bailey's and Coffee Blondie Bars

Melt in your mouth, tastes just like the delicious drink!

$2

Decorated Cookies

Choose from Shamrocks, Leprechaun Hats, Rainbows and Pots of Gold! $2-$3

Frosted Rainbow Butter Cookies

Our smiley face cookie gets an upgrade!

$2.50

LAYER CAKES

6" $28 8" $34 10" $44 Choice of Baileys, Guinness Stout or Thin Mint

Frango Mint Stuffed Chocolate Cookies

$1.75

Cookie Kit

8 asst shortbread (shamrocks, rainbows, hats) 2 bags of buttercream frosting and two packs of unique sprinkles.

$18

TOFFEE CARROT CAKE

2 layers of carrot cake with Toffee filling & Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting 6” $26 (6-8) 8” $32 (8-14) 10” $40 (16-20) 12” $52 (25-35)

GRANDMA EL'S COCONUT CAKE

2 layers of moist coconut cakes with coconut buttercream and shredded coconut 2 layers 6” $26 (6-8) 8” $32 (8-14) 10” $40 (16-20) 12” $52 (25-35)

MOM'S CHOCOLATE EASTER CAKE

2 layers of chocolate cake with fresh whipped cream filling, frosted with chocolate buttercream and topped with chocolate ganache! 6” $26 (6-8) 8” $32 (8-14) 10” $40 (16-20) 12” $52 (25-35)

THE SHEFFIELD

2 layers of white cake, filled with fresh raspberries, lemon curd & whipped cream, frosted with lemon buttercream. 6” $26 (6-8) 8” $32 (8-14) 10” $40 (16-20) 12” $52 (25-35)

LEMON BLUEBERRY LOVE

2 layers of lemon blueberry cake, filled with lemon curd filling. Frosted with Cream Cheese frosting. Decorated with birds nest & eggs. 6” $26 (6-8) 8” $32 (8-14) 10” $40 (16-20) 12” $52 (25-35)

BUNNY FACE LAYER CAKE

Choice of white, yellow or chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream filling and frosting. Sweet bunny face with fondant ears! 6” $35 (6-8) 8” $44 (8-14) 10” $50 (16-20) 12” $70 (25-35)

Coconut Cream or Banana Cream Pie

Topped with fresh whipped cream topping, Graham Cracker or Oreo Cookie Crust

$23

Strawberry Rhubarb, Blueberry, Cherry, Mixed Berry or Apple Pie

all butter crust filled with lot's of fruit!

$20

Key Lime Pie

$14

Bar and Cookies Platters

Assorted cookies and mini bars, with some decorated shortbread $25 small, $40 medium, $60 large

Buttercream Cupcakes

Chocolate or Yellow cake with Easter Decoration

$2.75

Decorated Easter Shortbread

Choose from Eggs, Bunnies, Carrots and Chicks! $2-$3

Flourless Chocolate Cake with Ganache Glaze GF

So rich and fudgey! 10" feeds 8-12 $34 8" feeds 6-10 $22

Chocolate Mousse Raspberry Pavlova Pie GF

Chocolate Mousse & fresh raspberries topped with fresh whipped cream in a meringue pavlova pie shell. 10" serves 6-10

$25

Lemon Raspberry Pavlova GF

Lemon curd & fresh raspberries topped with fresh whipped cream in a meringue pavlova pie shell. 10" serves 6-10

$25

Key Lime Pie

Tart and creamy in a matzoh meal crust

$15

Turtle Cheesecake

Chocolate Chip Cheesecake with a Chocolate Cookie Crust, topped with pecans, caramel, white & dark chocolates 6" $22 feeds 6-8, 10" feeds 8-14 $34

Caramel Apple Crostata

A rustic style open-face pie with an all butter matzoh meal crust and lot's of granny smith apples & caramel! large feeds 6-8 $15, or Individual size $4

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$1.25, or $1.50 dipped semi-sweet chocolate

Coconut Macaroons GF

Dipped or Un-Dipped $1.25 or $1.50 Plain, Chocolate Chip, Pineapple, Amaretto

S'mores Bars

$2.25

Carmelita's Bars

$2.25

Chocolate Chip Meringues GF

$1.25

Fudge Brownies

$2

Lemon Bars

$2

Banana Blondie Bar

$2

Matzo Toffee

With or without pecans, $4 1/4 lb. $7.50 1/2 lb. $15 full lb.

Mandel Brot

Chocolate Chip or Cinnamon Raisin

$0.90

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$1.10

Dipped $1.50

Ginger Molasses

$1.10

Frosted $1.50

Oatmeal Cranberry Pistachio White Chocolate

$1.35

Oatmeal Raisin

$1.10

m&m

$1.25

Oh My Chocolate

$1.10

Tons of Toffee

$1.35

Sprinkled Sugah

$1.10

Peanut Buttah-White Chocolate Toffee

$1.35

Double Dipped Peanut Buttah Cookies

$1.75

Snickerdoodles

$1.10

Smiley Face

$2

Cherry Pistachio Biscotti or Apricot-Almond Biscotti

$1.50

Dipped Chocolate Chip Macaroons

$1.50

Rugelach

cinnamon-raisin, raspberry-chocolate chip, apricot-walnut

$1.25

Kolachy’s

apricot or raspberry

$1.25

Peanut Buttah Buckeyes

$1.50

Stuffed Cookie of the day!

This week is Frango, omg delish!

$1.75

Decorated Shortbread Cookies

Our melt in your mouth cookies are made with white chocolate and sanding sugar. Variety of shapes and colors!

Custom Shortbread

Add your company or school logo, or even your face to our delicious shortbread cookies!

$2.25

Intense Brownies

$1.85

Caramel Walnut Brownies

$2

S’mores

$2

Carmelita’s

$2

PBJ Bars

$2

Sunny Lemon Bars

$1.85

7th Heaven Bars

$2

Raspberry Crumb Bars

$1.85

Coconut White Chocolate Blondie's

$1.85

Cherry Pie Bars

$2

Apple Pie Bars

$2

Double Vanilla

Double Chocolate

Yellow Cake with Chocolate top

Chocolate Cake with Vanilla top

Red Velvet

Salted Caramel

Cookies n' Cream

Chocolate Malt

Strawberry Fields

Lemon Oh!

Peanut Buttah

Carrot

Coconut

German Chocolate

S'mores

Whoopee Pies Chocolate or Vanilla

Chocolate or Vanilla Soft Sandwich Cookies with Marshmallow Creme Filling

$2.50

Mini's $1.50

HoHo’s

Everyday: chocolate cake rolled with fresh whip cream and dipped in chocolate! This months special is golden cake rolled with fresh strawberry whip cream and dipped in chocolate!

$2.95

Mini's $1.50

Cheesecake Lollipops

chocolate chip cheesecake rolled and dipped in semi-sweet chocolate with rainbow nonpareils

$1.50

Cookie Dough Lollipops

chocolate chip cookie dough rolled and dipped in semi-sweet chocolate with rainbow sprinkles

$1.50

Rice Krispy Lolli’s

$2.25

Mini's $1.25

Flourless Chocolate Cake

Decadent 10" one layer chocolate (no flour) topped with chocolate ganache and finished with chocolate buttercream edging.

$34

Fresh Fruit Crostata’s

A rustic style open face pie with an all-butter crust! Apple, Caramel Apple, or Mixed Berries.

Feeds 6-8 $14

Mini's each $3.75

Fruit Pies

Door County Cherry, Fresh Blueberry, Mom’s Apple, Mixed Berry Double crust pie made with our all butter crust

10” Full Size feeds 6-8 $18 - $20

Mini's personal siz $4.50

Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie $14

Southern Style Pecan Pie

$20

$5

County Fair Apple Pie

Our sugar cookie crust with loads of chopped apples, crumb topping and caramel drizzle!

$22

Not all styles & colors in store every day, call ahead for special designs.

Snowman, Mitten, Snowflakes, Flowers, Butterflies, Cupcakes, Baseballs, Footballs, Basketballs, Baby Bottles, Baby Buggies, Onesies, Wedding cakes, Wedding Dresses & MANY more!

6" feeds 4-8 $26

8" feeds 8-12 $32

10" feeds 12-18 $40

12". feeds 24-36 $52

1/4 sheet feeds 30-40 $56

Toffee Carrot Cake

Carrot cake with creamy toffee filling & cinnamon cream cheese frosting, Made with pecans, coconut & pineapple. Decorated with carrots

Mrs. Beebe’s Lemon Cake

Lemon cake, lemon curd center & lemon buttercream frosting, decorated with white buttercream daisies

Grandma El’s Coconut Cake

Moist coconut cake, coconut buttercream, covered with shredded coconut, with writing on top

Banana Fudge Cake

Banana cake, fudgy frosting, filled with banana slices, topped with chocolate buttercream swirls & confetti sprinkles

The Paisley Jane

Moist yellow cake with chocolate mousse filling, chocolate buttercream and chocolate rosettes on top

German’s Chocolate Cake

Chocolate cake, gooey coconut pecan filling & topping chocolate buttercream sides topped with chocolate swirls

Cookies & Cream Cake

Chocolate cake with cookies & cream filling & frosting. Decorated with vanilla swirls & mini Oreo cookies

Salted Caramel Cake

Chocolate Cake with caramel filling & salted caramel buttercream, drizzled with salted caramel, chocolate piping deco

Chocolate Malt Cake

Chocolate cake with chocolate malt filling and frosting. With vanilla swirls & chocolate malt balls

Strawberry Fields

Fresh strawberry cake, fresh strawberry frosting, whipped cream & fresh strawberry filling, topped with vanilla swirls

Funfetti Fantasy

White cake baked with rainbow sprinkles in the batter! Filled & frosted with vanilla buttercream, rainbow sprinkles on sides with rainbow dots on top

Toasted Almond

White Almond cake with Almond buttercream, sides coated in toasted almond crunch

The Sofie

White Wedding cake with Chocolate Mousse filling, frosted with Vanilla Buttercream, topped with Chocolate Ganache & buttercream swirls

Peanut Butter Rules

Chocolate Cake filled & frosted with Peanut Butter Buttercream, ganache poured over the top. Decorated with Reese’s PB cups!

The Sheffield

White wedding cake filled with fresh raspberries & lemon curd. Frosted in pale yellow lemon buttercream and finished with shades of pink rosettes.

Rainbow Dream Cake

5 layers of cake, red, orange, yellow, green & blue! With vanilla buttercream sprinkles in between the layers. Frosted in vanilla buttercream and covered in rainbow sprinkles. Add Pinata Sprinkle filling for a fun surprise! 8" $60, 10" $80, 12" $100 add Pinata Core of Sprinkles $15

S'Mores Cake

Chocolate Cake with Marshmallow Buttercream, ganache drip and graham cracker dusting. Garnish with our mini s'mores!