Menus
- Holiday Menu's
- Breakfast
- Wedding Cakes
- Cookies & Bars
- Platters
- Cookie Cakes & Cupcakes
- Pastries, Pies & More!
- Basic Cakes
- Specialty Cakes
- Vegan and Gluten Free
Mother's Day Menu
What a year to show Mom how much she is loved & appreciated!
In addition to our regular menu we offer..
All About Mom Layer Cake
2 layers of Chocolate Cake with Fresh Raspberries & Whipped Cream filling, chocolate buttercream frosting, and ganache dripping down!
6” $27 8” $34 10” $42
Banana Chocolate Chip Layer Cake
Banana Chocolate Chip Cake with Fudge Filling and Cream Cheese Frosting,
6” $26 8” $32 10” $40
The Sheffield
2 layers of white cake with filled with lemon curd, fresh raspberries & whipped cream. Frosted with lemon buttercream.
6” $26 8” $32 10” $40
Lemon Blueberry Love
Lemon blueberry cake with lemon curd filling and lemon buttercream frosting. Decorated with Light blue & Yellow flowers.
6” $26 8” $32 10” $40
Coconut Cream, Banana Cream or Chocolate Mousse Pie $22
Topped with fresh whipped cream topping, Oreo or Graham Cookie Crust
Key Lime Pie $15
Tart & creamy in a graham crust
Strawberry Rhubarb, Blueberry, Cherry, Mixed Berry or Apple Pie $20 all butter crust
Bar & Cookie Platters
Assortment of Bars, & Cookies
small $25 Medium $40 Large $60
Decorated Shortbread $2.25
Shortbread Hearts “Mom” or
Chalkboard Style “ We Love Mom”
Breakfast
-
Tea Breads
Banana or Banana Chocolate Chip, Pumpkin or Pumpkin Chocolate Chip $5.50
Lovely Lemon bread $6
-
Scones
Triple Berry, Cinnamon Chip, Chocolate Chunk $2.50
Mini's $1.25
-
8" Round Coffee Cakes
Buttermilk with Cinnamon Crumb top or Banana Chocolate Chip $12
8” rounds Fruit Streusel,Apple, Cherry, Blueberry, or Peach $13.50
-
Muffins
Blueberry, Cherry Almond, Cranberry-Walnut, Lemon-Poppy, Raspberry-Chocolate, Cherry-Chocolate Chunk, Almond Poppy
Large $3
Small $1.50
-
Sticky Cinnamon Rolls
Large $3.50
Small $2
-
Cinnamon Donut Muffins
$3.50
Wedding Cake Pricing
-
Level One
Minimal Decoration, Buttercream Frosted
per person $4.25
-
Level Two
Advanced Decoration, Buttercream Frosted
per person $5
-
Level Three
Advanced Decoration, Buttercream Frosted, Gumpaste Flowers
per person $6
-
Level Four
Minimal Decoration, Fondant
per person $8
-
Level Five
Advanced Decoration, Fondant
per person $10
Cake Flavors
White, Yellow, Chocolate, Strawberry, Banana, Coconut, Lemon, Pumpkin, Pistachio, Pound, CarrotFillings
-
Buttercreams
Vanilla, Chocolate, Fresh Raspberry, Lemon, Fresh Strawberry, Cream Cheese, Oreo, Mocha
-
Other Fillings
Chocolate Mousse, White Chocolate Mousse, Lemon Curd, Raspberry Mousse, Lemon Mousse, Fresh Berries
Buttercream Frostings
Vanilla, Chocolate, Lemon, Cream Cheese, Almond, Shredded Coconut, Tinted ColorsCake Guide: 2 layer
-
6" Serves 12
-
8" Serves 18
-
10" Serves 24
-
12" Serves 46
Cookies
Prices are for regular size, ‘mini’s’ are available too!-
Chocolate Chip Cookies
$1.10
Dipped $1.50
-
Ginger Molasses
$1.10
Frosted $1.50
-
Oatmeal Cranberry Pistachio White Chocolate
$1.35
-
Oatmeal Raisin
$1.10
-
m&m
$1.25
-
Oh My Chocolate
$1.10
-
Tons of Toffee
$1.35
-
Sprinkled Sugah
$1.10
-
Peanut Buttah-White Chocolate Toffee
$1.35
-
Double Dipped Peanut Buttah Cookies
$1.75
-
Snickerdoodles
$1.10
-
Smiley Face
$2
-
Cherry Pistachio Biscotti or Apricot-Sesame-Cashew Biscotti
$1.50
-
Dipped Chocolate Chip Macaroons
$1.50
-
Rugelach
cinnamon-raisin, raspberry-chocolate chip, apricot-walnut
$1.25
-
Kolachy’s
apricot or raspberry
$1.25
-
Peanut Buttah Buckeyes
$1.50
Bars
All bars can be cut in half for a ‘mini’ size-
Intense Brownies
$1.85
-
Caramel Walnut Brownies
$2
-
S’mores
$2
-
Carmelita’s
$2
-
PBJ Bars
$2
-
Sunny Lemon Bars
$1.85
-
7th Heaven Bars
$2
-
Raspberry Crumb Bars
$1.85
-
Coconut White Chocolate Blondie's
$1.85
-
Chocolate Chunk Blondie’s
$1.85
-
Cherry Pie Bars
$2
-
Apple Pie Bars
$2
-
Blueberry Bars
$2
Platters
All platters include a generous assortment of our most popular cookies & bars from above!-
Our Platters are made up of only our best selling cookies and bars. Cookies are available in mini or regular, but the bars are always mini size.
-
18 regular pieces or 25 mini’s
tray feeds 6-9
$25
-
32 regular pieces or 42 mini’s
tray feeds 10-16
$40
-
42 regular pieces or 54 mini’s
tray feeds 16-25
$50
-
64 regular pieces or 82 mini’s
tray feeds 25-34
$75
-
88 regular pieces or 114 mini’s
$100
Cookiecakes
Chocolate Chip or Old Fashioned Sugah-
Flowers, Polka Dots, Sports or Balloons & Inscription.
10” (8-14) $23
1/2 sheet (15-25) $35
Cupcakes
Not all flavors available in store every day, Custom Cupcakes to order!-
Buttercream Cupcakes
Yellow/Vanilla, Chocolate/Vanilla, Yellow/Chocolate, Chocolate/Chocolate, Red Velvet, Carrot, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Malt, Peanut Buttah, Banana/Chocolate, Coconut, Lemon Oh!, S’mores, Strawberry Fields, German Chocolate, Salted Caramel, Funfetti, Toasted Almond
Mini’s $1.25
Cupcakes start at $2.50
Baby Cakes $3.75
More Pastries
-
Whoopee Pies Chocolate or Vanilla
$2.50
Mini's $1.50
-
HoHo’s
$2.95
Mini's $1.50
Lolli Pops
-
Cheesecake Lollipops
$1.50
-
Cookie Dough Lollipops
$1.50
-
Rice Krispy Lolli’s
$2.25
Mini's $1.25
More...
-
Flourless Chocolate Cake
$34
Pies
-
Fresh Fruit Crostata’s
A rustic style open face pie with an all-butter crust! Apple, Caramel Apple, or Mixed Berries.
Feeds 6-8 $14
Mini's each $3.75
-
Fruit Pies
Door County Cherry, Fresh Blueberry, Mom’s Apple
10” Full Size feeds 6-8 $18 - $20
Mini's personal siz $4.50
-
Cream Pies 10" feeds 6-8
Graham or Chocolate Crust. Chocolate Mousse, Coconut, or Banana
$22
-
Other Pies
Key Lime Pie $14
Southern Pecan Pie $19
Mini Pecan Pie $5
Shortbread
Decorated Shortbread Starting at $2-
Not all styles & colors in store every day, call ahead for special designs.
Flowers, Butterflies, Cupcakes, Baseballs, Footballs, Basketballs, Baby Bottles, Baby Buggies, Onesies, Wedding cakes, Wedding Dresses & MANY more!
Basic Cakes
-
Layers
Chocolate, Yellow, or White cake.
-
Buttercream Frostings / Fillings:
Chocolate, Vanilla, Raspberry, Strawberry, Lemon, Oreo, Marshmallow, Cinnamon Cream Cheese
-
Special Fillings:
Lemon Curd, Fresh Whipped Cream, Chocolate Mousse, Fresh Strawberries, Raspberries, or Banana Slices
All Cakes are 2 Layers
-
6” (feeds 4-8)
$23
Special Filling $3
-
8” (feeds 8-12)
$28
Special Filling $4
-
10” (feeds 12-20)
$35
Special Filling $5
-
12” (feeds 25-35)
$48
Special Filling $6
-
1/4 sheet 2 layers feeds (25-36)
$48
Special Filling $7
-
2 layer 1/2 sheet feeds (60-66)
$70
Special Filling $9
Specialty Cakes
All cakes are 2 layers, any cake can be written on.
Any decoration other than stated will be an additional charge.
-
6" $26
8" $32
10" $40
12" $52
1/4 sheet $52
1/2 sheet 2 $78
-
Toffee Carrot Cake
Carrot cake with creamy toffee filling & cinnamon cream cheese frosting, Made with pecans, coconut & pineapple. Decorated with carrots
-
Mrs. Beebe’s Lemon Cake
Lemon cake, lemon curd center & lemon buttercream frosting, decorated with white buttercream daisies
-
Grandma El’s Coconut Cake
Moist coconut cake, coconut buttercream, covered with shredded coconut, with writing on top
-
Banana Fudge Cake
Banana cake, fudgy frosting, filled with banana slices, topped with chocolate buttercream swirls & confetti sprinkles
-
The Paisley Jane
Moist yellow cake with chocolate mousse filling, chocolate buttercream and chocolate shavings on top
-
German’s Chocolate Cake
Chocolate cake, gooey coconut pecan filling & topping chocolate buttercream sides topped with chocolate swirls
-
Cookies & Cream Cake
Chocolate cake with cookies & cream filling & frosting. Decorated with vanilla swirls & mini Oreo cookies
-
Salted Caramel Cake
Chocolate Cake with caramel filling & salted caramel buttercream, drizzled with salted caramel, chocolate piping deco
-
Chocolate Malt Cake
Chocolate cake with chocolate malt filling and frosting. With vanilla swirls & chocolate malt balls
-
Strawberry Fields
Fresh strawberry cake, fresh strawberry frosting, whipped cream & fresh strawberry filling, topped with vanilla swirls
-
Funfetti Fantasy
White cake baked with rainbow sprinkles in the batter! Filled & frosted with vanilla buttercream, rainbow sprinkles on sides with rainbow dots on top
-
Toasted Almond
White Almond cake with Almond buttercream, sides coated in toasted almond crunch
-
The Sofie
White Wedding cake with Chocolate Mousse filling, frosted with Vanilla Buttercream, topped with Chocolate Ganache & buttercream swirls
-
Peanut Butter Rules
Chocolate Cake filled & frosted with Peanut Butter Buttercream, ganache poured over the top. Decorated with Reese’s PB cups!
-
The Sheffield
White wedding cake filled with fresh raspberries & lemon curd. Frosted in pale yellow lemon buttercream and finished with shades of pink rosettes.
Vegan and Gluten Free
Every day in our store we have vegan brownies, gluten free brownies and gluten free cookies. You can order these options ahead of time:
Vegan
-
Assorted Cupcakes (min 6)
Chocolate, vanilla, carrot, strawberry, banana.
$3
-
Assorted Cookies
Ginger, snickerdoodle, choc chunk
$1.35
-
Pumpkin Bread (8 slices)
chocolate chunk, walnut or pecan
$12
-
Banana Bread (8 slices)
Chocolate chunk, walnut or pecan
$12
-
Scones
Triple-berry, lemon-blue, cherry-almond, cherry-chocolate
$3
-
Fudge Brownies
$2.25
Gluten Free
-
Assorted Cupcakes (min 6)
Chocolate, vanilla, carrot, strawberry, banana
$3
-
Assorted Cookies
Tons of toffee, ginger, snickerdoodle, choc chunk, sugah
$1.35
-
Fudge Brownies
$2.25
Vegan and Gluten-Free
-
Banana Chocolate Oat Cake 8"
$14
-
Blueberry Banana Oat Cake 8"
$14
Vegan OR Gluten Free
-
Layer Cakes
Can be ordered GF or Vegan. Cake Flavors: Chocolate, vanilla, banana, carrot or strawberry Fillings & Frostings: Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, lemon or raspberry buttercreams.
6" $28
8" $34